>>35867

"if a girl gets into trouble by her own action or not makes enough effort to resist/escape that's consensual already." No, by my definition that's clearly non-consensual.
"In the previous CDL story, those girls came to rapists themselves and even were quite excited with all that torture perspectives ;)"
They had some silly fantasies, but it was very clear they didn't want these things to happen, clearly everything was non-consensual.
"as if girls mention that she wants to be raped and later it happens does it counts as consensual?"
Rape can never be consensual by definition. Lots of girls have rape fantasies, if they get raped it's still non-consensual.
"of if she is given a chance to escape but she decided not to use it. will it count as consensual for you?"
This might be an edge case sometimes, but it's probably still non-consensual.
"or another version which I actually like most were girl wants to suffer but also screams cries and reacts normally while being tortured."
If she wants it, it's probably consensual. It's certainly not a fantasy I want to see.

Other edge cases could be a girl who agrees with everything at first but then changes her mind - that would also be non-consensual. Or a girl who doesn't agree at first but then changes her mind - I'm not sure how to classify that, but it's not what I'm looking for. There are maybe some non-consensual elements in your stories, but so far your girls at least mostly agree with the things that are happening to them, and that's just not what I'm looking for.

I want the girls to hate what's done to them. They can show that in different ways, some might try to fight back, some might complain, some might beg and scream and some might suffer silently. It just has to be very clear that they don't want these things to happen, they are just unable to stop them. If it looks like the girl is enjoying what's happening to her and actually wants that to happen, it's not interesting for me any more.

Drabok does exactly that with lots of torture scenes, including stuff I haven't seen anybody else do. And to me it's looking very good. About quality vs quantity: Sure, I have seen 3D artists who are objectively making better pictures than either Drabok or Onix. But they are producing single pictures, and have an output of maybe 1 or 2 pictures every month. Among artists with a similar output who are focusing on stories instead of single pictures, it's hard to find better quality. And I always prefer stories over single pictures. Even if these stories are sometimes just loosely connected torture scenes. A story with more background story and other elements might be more interesting, but on the other hand I have seen some artists start stories like that and then stop updating when they get to the action scenes, so I'm happy with the way Drabok's stories usually don't take very long to get into these action scenes.