all / g / s / fur / art / ai / 3dcg / f / rp / req / p2p / dis / lit / kaki chat
[Settings] [Home] [Catalog] [Search] [Thread list] [Stats] [Reports] [Watcher] [PMs] [Admin]
[Return]

Report a post

Preview
No.5070
▶
>>5062

CASE: INTENT
Dude 1 kills dude 2. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 1 pushes dude 2. Dude 2 trips, hits his head, and passes away in the hospital. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 1 operates machinery and didn't know dude 2 was in the way. Dude 2 dies. Is dude 1 a murderer?

CASE: SELF DEFENSE
Dude 2 insults dude 1. Dude 1 kills dude 2. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 2 hits dude 1. Dude 1 kills dude 2. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 2 tries to stab dude 1. Dude 1 kills dude 2. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 2 tries to stab dude 1. Dude 1 struggles away and pushes dude 2. Dude 2 falls on his knife and dies. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Dude 2 goes on a shooting rampage. Dude 1 kills dude 2 to prevent any more shots. Is dude 1 a murderer?

Just for context the law has to handle far more shades of grey than this.
Post number No.5070
Board Discussion
Optional. Describe what's wrong with it.