With the note of I actually have a legit phobia of the genre (saw a bit of one of the Freddy Krueger movies at WAY too young at a Walt Disney World resort, I have and am doing therapy for it, and I'm almost where I want to be in terms of the phobia)

Silent Hill. The first movie. The second, while enjoyable, is Action Adventure with Horror elements.

I have a SOLID crush on Pyramid Head, the nurses are hot as fuck, and my only problem is handing the hot police woman the idiot ball.

The sequel is enjoyable, but I was very disappointed in it as I was hoping it would progress my therapy, and. Well. Not actually horror.