Heh, fair enough.^^

Alright, let me see, between those two I'd probably lean more towards Maylene. I can think of two scenarios right now, either something along the lines of Team Galactic taking over the city, stealing pokemon and trainers for experiments, planning general villain stuff etc, and her setting out to defeat them and protect her city as the gym leader. Naturally that doesn't go as planned and instead she finds herself caught instead, which could subsequently result in something akin to making an example out of her to intimidate anybody that dares stand in their way. This could be accomplished through an execution or some sort of experiment, or a broadcasted snuff video for example?

The other idea is more small-scale. Maybe a previous challenger once comfortable defeated/humiliated/schooled Maylene in a gym battle and ever since she has been vying and training harder than ever before to improve herself. Maybe she spends most of her days outside training in the woods or mountains, with her eventually running in the previous challenger again who, by then, has already conquered the whole region and is on his way to the pokemon league or so. Either way, she confidently/arrogantly challenges him for a rematch but, again, is easily defeated and this time the challenger takes things even farther? This could potentially lead to rape, excessive violence, choking and something along the lines of hanging her from a tree branch or, if they were to run across another in the mountains, something like stumbling, falling off a cliff?

Though I suppose that would depend on whether the challenger was truly evil (in which case he could also steal her pokemon or even be affiliated with one of the crime organisations) or if the death is more of an unfortunate accident. When things get too heated. I mean, heck, even something along the lines of her personally assaulting him after her pokemon are defeated could be fun to read, and him simply paying her back in kind?

Anyways, would either of those scenarios work for you? If not I could probably come up with different ones. Also, of course I'm not asking to write out the battle itself as that could get quite long-winded. ^^