> If it is consensual it is not rape LOL
> I think you could solve that if Sakura only talks with that guy over internet and sets situation in a way he kidnaps and tortures her without knowing that she is one who staged all that, so he still thinks he is raping her against her will.
> Homeles guys as rapists, is not very good idea, because usually homeless guys are quite nice and very unlikely to hurt or hate someone. But this is common in manga for some reson
> Eating immobile chocolate statue is nothing special, it is just statue even if it was human some time ago.
> so second option is better, but also since it is fantasy, why bother with turning body parts to chocolate if it can be all chocolate and stay alive and mobile?
> But you really need enormous appetite to eat whole Sakura in one go.
> so i think instead of Sakura using magic on herself she could just return from one of her fights turned into chocolate and Tomoyo finds our that she is very tasty.
> as you often say this is guro story, so we can imagine it any way.
> No she did not lost battle, it just happens that she was turned into chocolate(something like princess Bubblegum who is made out of chewing gum) and did not noticed that ,maybe she just absorbed The Sweet's powers. She is not eaten by Tomoyo alone either. Tomoyo just finds out about her strange condition and they discuss what to do next. It can be no less consensual because she can offer herself when she notices how good she tastes. At first they just sample her to see what happened and later she eventually gets eaten completely.
> It seems that your main idea is to make Sakura sacrifice herself on purpose instead of random accident.
> But still just turning body parts into real chocolate is not that appealing because that will be just eating chocolate made from her body not Sakura
> I still think it would be better to limit transformation to the taste only while visually there should be no changes
>you need awful lot of balloons to suffocate someone so it is hardly possible to do as accident.
> But what I was saying that you must find a reason to put those balloons on her neck.
> I wonder how that suffocation will happen: will she just stop moving eventually and tomoyo will notice that she is dead? OR they will walk away from shooting range and Tomoyo will notice that she is dragging dead body or maybe Sakura will fly away and die in the sky?
>yes, this is good, also because balloons take away most of the weight she can walk even while suffocating without falling down.