all
/
g
/
s
/
fur
/
art
/
ai
/
3dcg
/
f
/
rp
/
req
/
p2p
/
dis
/
lit
/
kaki
chat
GUROchan!
This list is WIP...
1
2
3
So use the classic menu
Link 4
Link 5
Link 6
Link 7
List 3
Link 8
Link 9
[
Settings
]
[
Home
] [
Catalog
] [
Search
] [
Thread list
] [
Stats
] [
Reports
] [
Watcher
] [
PMs
] [
Admin
]
Literature
[
Return
]
Report a post
Preview
Aoi Hikari
2021/03/16
(Tue)
11:15:09
No.
21934
[
Report
]
▶
>>14077
Well, my favorite is the one with the twins of course :-)
There's something inexplicably wholesome about killing your beloved twin sister, the closest person you have in the world, your other half, just to help her win a childish game like that, and of course both of you being perfectly fine with that and finding it to be a great idea. There is no malice in it, no regret, no feeling of sacrifice, but only wholesome familial love, from both sides too.
If I could change one thing about this story, I'd probably add more focus on the emotions between the twins.
If I could change one other thing, I have an idea which I'm not that sure about, but it involves making the competition more fair by making Tristan hold Sophia down too (so maybe he can like hug each of the girls around their necks with his arms and hold them down like that?) Maybe Sophia notices he's helping his sister and demands he holds her down too to be fair, or maybe from the start they decide to do it this way this time. Anyway, the end would be that Sophia still loses, because in the end she loses to her instinct and fights and breaks away from Tristan's hold and resurfaces to take a breath. While for Kristen an instinct to unquestioningly trust her other half it stronger than the survival instinct, so she feels comfort in him holding her down and keeps calm and doesn't fight. But she's still aware it would end with her dying, so the trust is not like she trusts that he won't kill her, but that the comforting/calming effect of the one killing her being her brother is stronger than the panicking effect from her lungs burning. Do I make sense?
But as I say, I'm not that sure about that second change, because it might be just overcomplicate the story too much.
The hide-and-seek one is good too. Is it inspired by my 100 words story where Rin decides to kill herself while playing hide-and-seek, arguing that even if Len finds her corpse, there'll be no 'her' anywhere to find?
If I could change one thing about this story, it would be Sally's attitude of "everyone's going to talk about me". I know I said I wanted a smug attitude, but I didn't mean... eh... what's the word?.. hunger for glory?..
Because the way you phrase it, "everyone would say that Sally Smith was the best hide & seek player ever!" somehow sounds too... hm... too elaborate, maybe? It's like... on one hand it shows her being overly concerned about other people's opinion, and at the same time that only makes her come off only more egotistical?
While what I would have preferred is Sally doing it just for the immediate goal of winning the game. And she wants to win the game not for the sake of some glory and being talked about, but just because that's what you do in games - you try to win them.
Yes, this. Now that I've said this, I see that the attitude you gave her kinda undermines the casualness of it. Because when children usually play games, they try to win just because that's what the game consists of. Not because they want to be talked about for ages to come as a legendary hide-and-seek player. So when Sally talks about how people would talk about her, it puts it as if her jumping into the flames is not just an organic part of playing hide-and-seek. While the point of casual guro is the opposite: to make it feel like it is indeed just an organic part of the game.
If I could change one more thing, that would actually be not making her undress, as leaving her clothes is going against her goal of hiding. Or course, you say it will only be found much later, but Sally doesn't know it, and it makes it look stupid, because she's doing deliberate actions, taking time and effort to undress, which would only result in her being found more easily.
If you want to include nudity somewhere, a more logical place would be, of course, in the twins' story, where it could be just shown as a natural part of swimming that it is done naked. In a world where nudity is not considered indecent, who would want to wear a wet peace of cloth on them? Eew.
As for the third story, I guess it's just okay. It's not bad, but it just doesn't evoke as much emotions in me as the other stories. Maybe because the actual action part is too short. In the twins' story it takes some time for Kristen to drown, in Sally's story while the actual burning part is short, it takes some time for her to prepare for it (so I guess there is something good in her undressing after all, as it prolongs the main part of the story giving a bit more time to savor it before it's all over).
So maybe if I wanted to change one thing about this story, it would be to add something more to the last part of it, maybe have each girl's motivation expanded just a bit, like maybe one of them doesn't really mind the boys, but just decides to go along with her friends because doing things together with friends is just fun by itself.
Overall I guess, seeing how all these stories are very short, I wouldn't mind them being more expanded. But then again, since them being so short is a trade off for having three stories for the price of one, I'm not really complaining. Indeed, having three stories all with interesting ideas, even if they end too soon, still gives me three times more different inspiring ideas.
And if you think the more I say I enjoy the story the more I seem to want to change about it, which might sound counter-intuitive, that's because the more it moves me emotionally the more it inspires me, it makes me thing about itself more and that's why I come up with more ideas about improving it. Makes sense?
Post number
No.
21934
Board
Literature
Reason
Optional. Describe what's wrong with it.
Style: