Good fight.

Looks like Ice prevails over Fire, this time around...

I'm considering altering the rules a bit, so that even those characters who lose a fight can be used again, but with no potential for rematches against the one who defeated them. (Elesis, for example, couldn't fight Rukia [who defeated her] or Lucy [who was defeated BY her])

Under the original rules, we now have available:

Erza Scarlet
Rukia Kuchiki [One win against Elesis]
Jam

This enables the following matchups:

Erza vs. Rukia
Erza vs. Jam
Rukia vs. Jam

Now, if we were to do the new rules I'm proposing, we'd have available:

Elesis (Blazing Heart) [One win against Lucy, one loss against Rukia]
Lucy [One loss against Elesis]
Erza Scarlet
Rukia Kuchiki [One win against Elesis]
Jam

This would enable the following matchups:

Elesis vs. Erza
Elesis vs. Jam
Lucy vs. Erza
Lucy vs. Rukia
Lucy vs. Jam
Erza vs. Lucy
Erza vs. Rukia
Erza vs. Jam
Rukia vs. Jam

Would people rather stick with the old rules or go with the new ones? And which fight does someone want to tackle next?