Wasn't thinking of including Lolis... might need to do a separate thread for Lolis.

Anyway, the updated roster is:

Elesis (Blazing Heart) [One win against Lucy, one loss against Rukia]
Lucy [One loss against Elesis, one win against Jam]
Erza Scarlet
Rukia Kuchiki [One win against Elesis]
Jam [One loss against Lucy]
Ran Mouri/Rachael Moore

And the potential matchups are now:

Elesis vs. Erza
Elesis vs. Jam
Elesis vs. Ran/Rachael
Lucy vs. Erza
Lucy vs. Rukia
Lucy vs. Ran/Rachael
Erza vs. Lucy
Erza vs. Rukia
Erza vs. Jam
Erza vs. Ran/Rachael
Rukia vs. Jam
Rukia vs. Ran/Rachael
Jam vs. Ran/Rachael

So, who will tackle which fight next?