Nice work with the fight. :)

OK, Roster Update:

Elesis (Blazing Heart) [One win against Lucy, one loss against Rukia]
Lucy [One loss against Elesis, two wins {one against Jam, one against Ran/Rachael}]
Erza Scarlet [One win against Makoto, one loss against Black Fire]
Rukia Kuchiki [One win against Elesis]
Jam [One loss against Lucy]
Ran Mouri/Rachael Moore [One loss against Lucy]
Makoto [One loss against Erza]
Black Fire [One win against Erza]

And the potential matchups are now:

Elesis vs. Erza
Elesis vs. Jam
Elesis vs. Ran/Rachael
Elesis vs. Makoto
Elesis vs. Black Fire
Lucy vs. Erza
Lucy vs. Rukia
Lucy vs. Makoto
Lucy vs. Black Fire
Erza vs. Lucy
Erza vs. Rukia
Erza vs. Jam
Erza vs. Ran/Rachael
Rukia vs. Jam
Rukia vs. Ran/Rachael
Rukia vs. Makoto
Rukia vs. Black Fire
Jam vs. Ran/Rachael
Jam vs. Makoto
Jam vs. Black Fire
Ran/Rachael vs. Makoto
Ran/Rachael vs. Black Fire
Makoto vs. Black Fire

So, everyone currently in the roster has fought at least once - let's see which fight happens next...